NOTICE TO READER
The information in this article is a brief summary for informational purposes only and is only applicable in the Province of Ontario. It is not meant to be legal advice. If you require information or advice as it relates to your individual circumstances you are advised to consult with the Law Office of Peter Cusimano or speak to your own lawyer.
by: Peter Cusimano, B.Sc., LL.B.; Toronto Business Lawyer
I have addressed below various issues and complaints that people have when dealing with their lawyers.
The impression some people have of lawyers is that lawyers charge exorbitant fees; they take too long to complete the work; they always do more than is necessary; they take forever to return phone calls; they messed up a good deal; they are generally sharks and ambulance-chasers out to get people and their money.
When people become involved in the legal process for whatever reason, they often try to use their impression of lawyers to their advantage: they expect the lawyer to come in and easily get them out of the mess that somehow they've fallen into; they expect that their problem can be solved overnight; they want the lawyer to get them out of their situation on a "technicality"; and they want the lawyer to fix the great injustice that has happened to them.
If any of the above describes your impressions of lawyers then you may be greatly disappointed with the service you receive from your lawyers. Although there are lawyers in the profession who can be characterized by the above, this article attempts to demystify these myths and describes what you should expect from your legal professional and how to ensure that you are satisfied with the work.
Every lawyer has different experiences and resources available to do your legal work for you. Just as there are various areas in medicine, there are various areas in law. For example, there are lawyers that restrict their practice to certain areas such as family law, business law, immigration law, criminal law, real estate law, litigation law, etc... Some lawyers are also general practitioners that practice many areas. You wouldn't go to a dentist to ask about your sore foot. Likewise, make sure you speak to the right type of lawyer. The good news is that most lawyers should be able to direct you another lawyer that knows how to deal with your sitatuation. In addition, some lawyers work in large downtown law firms while others are one-person operations. Do not think that the bigger the firm the better the service. Sometimes you will get better service at a smaller firm. However, sometime you may require the resources of a large firm.
Different lawyers also have different approaches to solving problems. Decide what is important to you and find a lawyer who has the same approach to solving your problem. Do you want a shark? Or do you want a compassionate lawyer? Is the principle of the matter more important than the legal and emotional cost? Some lawyers are more than anxious to fight your case in court whether or not you have a reasonable case. On the other hand, other lawyers would advise you to do everything possible to stay out of court and would prefer to negotiate a settlement for you. There are also lawyers who are competitors and who will do everything to legally take advantage of the other side in the name of business whether or not it makes good business sense for you. Other lawyers will recommend that your relationship with the other party is more important than fighting over which party is right and which party is wrong.
If you don't know a lawyer, ask your friends if they know one. Ask your accountant to recommend a lawyer. You can also look in the Yellow Pages under "Lawyers" which also includes a listing for the Lawyer Referral Service which is a free service operated by the Law Society of Upper Canada (the governing body of lawyers in Ontario) that will refer you to a lawyer.
Above all choose a lawyer that you feel comfortable dealing with.
Sometimes keeping your deal simple is very difficult to achieve and can be very expensive to do so. Some matters are by their nature very complicated. Many times lawyers will recommend a course of action that you may think is just make work for the lawyer and just more "legal mumbo jumbo" that you will never read let alone ever need.
Before rejecting any recommendation by your lawyer, you should carefully think of the consequences of your action. Remember, the lawyer is trying to protect your interests that will save you money over the long term. For example, in making a decision to buy a house or selling a business you may think that making the decision is the hard-part and then it is just a matter of completing the formalities by the lawyers.The truth is that decisions frequently cannot be implemented immediately because your decision has raised additional issues and problems that need to be addressed and resolved. Would you tell the police who were looking for your missing child to keep it "simple" and to "not spend much time" on your case? Of course not. You wouldn't ask the same of a surgeon about to operate on you. No surgeon would operate on that basis. If you don't understand why a lawyer is recommending a certain course of action, then be sure to ask the lawyer (i) the purpose of the action, (ii) the consequences of taking the action, (iii) the consequences of not taking the action. Make sure that your decisions are informed ones made after careful thought and not based on emotion.
Before you jump to conclusions you should discuss with the lawyer what his/her fee entails. What may seem "simple" to you may in fact require complicated legal analysis or many steps. For example, buying or selling a business involves more than just finding a buyer/seller and handing over the money. A "simple" purchase and sale of a house could easily involve 30 inquiries being conducted and a search of everyone who has owned the property for the past 40-years. Alternatively, you may think that you are the only person in the world that has your problem which is not true. You are not the first person to get divorced or to suffer "great legal injustice".
In a civil dispute, you may also feel that you are clearly right and you have done nothing wrong. You cannot understand why it takes so long to complete your matter and why it costs so much especially if you "know" you are "right". The truth is that if you were so "right" then the other side would agree to settle the dispute. Even though you may think you are "right", chances are that you have done certain actions or failed to do certain actions that have resulted in a misunderstanding between the parties. Always discuss with your lawyer both the weaknesses and the strengths of your matter.
Although you should shop around for a lawyer be sure that you do not choose a lawyer solely based on price. Since all lawyers are not alike, the cheapest is not always the best. In addition, you may discover that there are many hidden costs that a "cheap" lawyer does not tell you until it is too late.
Most lawyers operate on an hourly basis. Lawyers keep track of the amount of time that they spend on your file. Every time a lawyer works on your file, the following information is recorded: (1) description of work, (2) time spent, (3) date, (4) amount charged. This information should be provided to you when you receive your invoice. Do not accept an invoice from a lawyer that simply says "For Professional Services Rendered" without the foregoing information also included. Many lawyers also offer a "flat" fee service for certain services. However, in some matters a flat fee is almost impossible to give because it depends on how the other party acts and on many factors beyond the control of the lawyer.
Before lawyers commence doing work, they will request from you money that they will hold in a special bank account called a "lawyer's trust account". This money is called a "retainer fee". The money deposited in a lawyer's trust account does not belong to the lawyer. The lawyer is holding on the money for the people who are entitled to the money. As the lawyer commences work and sends you a bill or incurs expenses on your behalf, the money will be taken from the money held in trust as a retainer fee. After your matter is completed, the lawyer will refund back to you any extra money that is remaining in the lawyer's trust account that belongs to you.
A disbursement is an out-of-pocket expense that lawyers must incur on your behalf. Common examples of disbursements that will be charged to you include:
This concept is called "contingency fees". In the province of Ontario, the law does not permit lawyers to charge by way of contingency fees. Whether you win or not you are responsible to pay your lawyer's fees. If you win at court, you may be entitled to ask the other side to pay some or all of your legal fees. Although you may think that if you lose your case, then your lawyer did a poor job and does not deserve to get paid, the truth may be that the judge simply decided that he/she did not believe your case or that the law does not support your position. Consider the example of your loved pet accidentally swallowing some poisonous cleaner and the veterinarian does everything he/she can do to save the pet but unfortunately the pet does not make it and dies. Should the veterinarian get paid even though the pet died? Of course.
You pay your lawyer to represent your best interests. For example, if you are buying a house, you pay your lawyer to find out for you everything that can go wrong and to adequately protect your interests. Although you may be in love with the house because it is your "dream home" it is your lawyer's job to make sure that there is nothing wrong and to ensure that your interests are protected. What happens if the lawyer tells you to delay completing the deal until he/she can have soil tests conducted. Is the lawyer messing up the deal for you? If it is subsequently discovered that your "dream home" is contaminated with radioactive material that the sellers conveniently failed to tell you or didn't know about, then you'll be glad you found out in advance.
In another example, people complain that lawyers appear to mess up a deal because they are negotiating over issues that appear to be trivial matters that are unlikely to occur. The lawyers are there to protect you. For example, you may be buying into a business not realizing who you are dealing with. You would not be too happy to turn over a large amount of money to a seller only to discover that a bank is the true owner of the assets purchased or that the business you are purchasing has a million dollar lawsuit pending against it.
People are frequently frustrated that lawyers never tell them what are the chances of winning their case. In addition, people complain that lawyers answer their questions with a phrase such as "it depends" and often lawyers refuse to give black-and-white yes-or-no answers. The truth is that many times there is no straightforward answer. The law is not perfect and the law does not always contain the answer. Often the answers to your questions depend on the position of the other side. In a civil dispute, the answer to whether you win or not often depends on whether your version of the facts is more reasonable than the other side's version of the facts and the only way to find out is to go to court and ask a judge to answer the question. If the answer to your question can be answered with a clear yes-or-no, more than likely there would not be a dispute between the parties.
If you are not happy with your lawyer, do not feel that you are stuck and can't change lawyers. Remember that you are entitled to change lawyers at any time, however, you are still responsible to pay for the work completed to date. Before changing lawyers consider the following: tell your lawyer you are not happy; explain what you are not happy about; ask the lawyer what can be done to change the situation.
Before you conclude that your lawyer is not helping you, keep in mind the following points.
Become actively involved with your lawyer in the legal process and the solution of your situation. Listen to your lawyer. Do not try to do things that are best left to your lawyer. Be sure to tell your lawyer everything about your situation, including the good, bad, and embarrassing. Know in advance what you want your lawyer to do for you.